Follow
Share

I cannot convince the 86 year old man I am a live-in caregiver to pay me as little as twenty dollars a day. He is clearly a covert narcissist who feels entitled to keep me here as his personal slave. I spent all my savings to rescue him from sure death in a nursing home after he had brain surgery to remove a fungal ball. He is my ex's father. At the time I was grateful to have a place to stay during covid. I was paid some in the beginning by his grown children who were aware he had money hoarding issues. He has recovered but is high risk of falling. I'm thinking seriously of taking him to small claims to get back some of my lost wages. What do you think?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Without knowing the full story, it sounds like a good deal was made during the height of Covid that suited you both: care for accomodation.

Since the deal no longer works for you, time to move on.

Find new accomodation, let him know the date you are leaving. Advice he will need to make other care arrangements. Help him call his local Area of Aging if you wish to help start the process.

The lost wages are broken promises. Hard to prove without a work contract. Avoid bitterness, just move on.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

One option that may only work in some circumstances, and involves a bit of work. Tell your ex and the ‘grown children’ that you are going to lodge a claim in the Small Claims Court. You are also going to all the local media to give them this as an example of something that happens far to often when families get together to get ‘free care’ by exploiting someone who is too trusting.

To avoid it being blatant blackmail, you probably need to be ready to lodge the claim and you need to check out the local media. In other words, be ready to do it for real, out of genuine indignation about what’s happened to you (and to too many others). It’s a good ‘human interest’ story. You don't say 'unless you pay up I am going to...'. You say 'I am going to' and wait for them to suggest a pay up.

If it goes to Court, you won’t win. But there are other wins besides court. They may choose to settle.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

If you have been paid under the table, I would not take him to court. You would be going in with "unclean" hands as Judge Judy calls them. 😊 What that means is as a live-in the IRS considers you an employee. This man and his family should be paying u a wage, making payroll deductions, and sending those deductions to the appropriate agencies. They then give u a W2 form so u can pay taxes. I think this man feels giving you a place to stay is your pay. You are being treated like a slave. He seems to need more help than you can give. When u get that phone u need to tell the ex you are leaving and he needs to make arrangements in LTC for his Dad. You then go to Social Services and ask them if they can help you with lodging, money and voucher for food. Just tell them you were hired as live-in and promised a wage, which you received initially but it has stopped. So, you had to walk away because u were expected to do caring 24/7 for a roof over u head.

Never spend money on others you need for yourself. Never do any Caregiving job without a contract and everything on the up and up. There are laws for live-ins. You only work a certain # of hours a day with time off. Family either hires another aide to fill in or does the caring.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I am 60 years old. I was promised by my ex I would be paid and I was paid in the beginning. Doesn't that prove I was hired? I left out the part where he fell and broke his neck last year. His dysphagia from the brain surgery returned even worse than before. You know, blended meals, neck brace for six months. Once again I was paid ($200 a week) by his grown children for the extra work but then the money eventually stopped. His neck never did heal. He has fallen five times since the brain surgery. Always lands on his forehead. I can't believe how he can possibly be living. I never dreamed he would survive brain surgery, let alone breaking his neck in four places! I can't even afford a cell phone to get a job. He blocks every call that comes in on his landline due to robo-calls. Yes, I would have a hard time leaving a vulnerable adult. But believe me, I am ready to move on. I've got my van all set up to live in. I could do it if I took him to small claims. The man gets $5000 a month in retirement! As soon as I get my new free gvmnt phone activated I will be finding a job. No doubt about that.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Geaton777 Sep 2023
Did your ex promise your verbally? If so, it doesn't prove anything (unless maybe you provide a witness). Would you be suing your ex? Or the elder you provide care for?

Did they pay you $200 a week in checks with a notation in the memo line saying what the check were for? Or did they pay you cash? If it was cash, there's no paper trail. If there's no notation on the checks, it is he said/she said situation.

Also, if you were being paid, were you reporting it on your income taxes? If so, how?

I'm glad you have the option to live somewhere (in your van). How much are you going to sue him for? In my state the max is $15K. Go to the Concilliation Court website for the state. You should be able to download packets of forms. This will tell you if you have enough to prove your case. If you do get it into the court system, and even if you win, the money won't come to you very quickly if he doesn't just write you a check... garnishment takes a while.
(0)
Report
I think you should move out and have no further contact with this gentleman who is not a part of your family. You, of course cannot get back any lost wages given it was by your own free choice you moved in, you stayed, and you paid no rental. Wish you the best.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

You can’t if you have no employment or payment contract. You said you exchanged caregiving for a place to stay.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
anonymous1784938 Sep 2023
You chose to light yourself on fire to keep him warm. That was sweet and all of that but your actions had consequences. This is all you’re doing it sounds like.
(2)
Report
It's true that without a written contract you have nothing to present in court.

Even if you could get him to sign an employment contract, it's complicated to be his privately hired in-home caregiver as this makes him an actual employer. Then he has to comply with the employment rules for his state, and do the whole SS and Medicare withholding/contribution with every paycheck, create a W2 every year, do quarterly deposits, etc. Highly unlikely.

Therefore, I support those who say you should move out. Don't tell him -- just go and then call social services before you actually leave, or notify his children that you're leaving. Don't give any reason except you don't want to do it anymore (if you give a reason they will negotiate with you and you might cave in). Be done with him and move on. APS will take care of all his needs.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Is this for real?
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Without some sort of contract, you can’t make him pay. The longer you stay, the worse things are for you. I’d suggest that before you move out, you tell his adult children that you will be going and why. You may be able to negotiate with them some back payment to keep you there while they work out what to do with him. That will get over the 'stuck' because you don't have funds to leave.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

You will be wasting your money in small claims court unless you have a signed contract outlining your pay scale and hours.

I think that you should pack your bags and leave, go to a shelter and get your life back on track.

Nothing changes, if nothing changes, time for you to make a change!

Good Luck!
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

I think you need to get a job and move out.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
sp196902 Sep 2023
Obvious solution and yet....OP will give us a song and dance about not wanting to leave him alone because he's just a helpless old nan. As if...this guy had an unpaid slave for 3 plus years. OP has backed herself into a corner with no money and no place to live.
(3)
Report
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter